Nutritional Disclaimer: This recipe is intended for general informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical or dietary advice. Consult a registered dietitian or your healthcare provider before making dietary changes, especially if you have a health condition. Read our full Medical & Nutritional Disclaimer.
Finding lunch ideas for weight loss that are actually filling is harder than it sounds. This guide covers 25 simple high-protein meals built for real life, whether you are meal prepping for the week or pulling something together in under 30 minutes. No bland diet food. Just honest recipes that support your goals and taste good doing it.
SaveTable of Contents
Why Lunch Matters for Weight Loss
Most people spend a lot of energy planning breakfast and dinner then grab whatever is convenient at noon. That midday decision made when you are tired, busy and already hungry is often where a weight-loss plan quietly falls apart.
Lunch is not just another meal. It sits at the center of your day and directly shapes your energy, your afternoon hunger and how much you eat at dinner. A lunch that is too light leaves you raiding the pantry at 3pm. A lunch that is heavy and carb-loaded triggers an energy crash that makes the rest of the day harder than it needs to be.
The good news is that eating well at lunch does not require complicated recipes or hours in the kitchen. You just need meals that are built around the right principles and this guide covers exactly that.
For more inspiration across every meal of the day check out our full collection of 22 Best Homemade Weight Loss Recipes That Actually Work.
The Midday Meal Most People Get Wrong
The most common lunch mistake is choosing something that looks healthy but lacks protein and fiber. A small green salad with a low-fat dressing, a plain sandwich on white bread or a store-bought wrap with more tortilla than filling will leave most people hungry within two hours. When that happens willpower is not enough. You will eat and you will likely eat more than you planned.
The fix is straightforward. Build your lunch around protein and fiber first then add everything else around them.
What Makes a Good Weight Loss Lunch
Protein, Fiber and Volume
A well-constructed lunch for weight loss has three things working together.
Protein is the most important. It takes longer to digest, keeps you full and supports muscle mass while you are in a calorie deficit. Aim for at least 25 to 35 grams of protein per lunch. Chicken, eggs, shrimp, canned fish, cottage cheese and legumes are all strong choices.
Fiber slows digestion and feeds the gut bacteria that influence hunger hormones. Vegetables, legumes and whole grains all contribute here. A lunch that includes two or more cups of vegetables will consistently outperform one that skips them.
Volume is the psychological piece. A large bowl of soup, a big salad or a stuffed pepper feels like more food than a small sandwich even if the calorie count is similar or lower. Choosing high-volume lower-calorie foods helps you feel satisfied without going over your daily target.
What to Limit Without Feeling Deprived
You do not need to eliminate anything. But a few habits consistently work against weight loss at lunch.
Liquid calories from sweetened drinks, juices or creamy soups made with heavy cream add up fast without contributing to fullness. Large portions of refined carbohydrates eaten without protein alongside them cause blood sugar spikes that lead to afternoon crashes and cravings. Sauces and dressings added without measuring are the most common source of hidden calories in otherwise healthy meals.
None of this means eating plain food. It means being intentional. The recipes in this guide are all built to be genuinely satisfying and not just technically low in calories.
High-Protein Lunch Ideas for Weight Loss
Protein is the foundation of a weight-loss lunch. These five recipes deliver on flavor and fullness without requiring a long time in the kitchen.
1. Fluffy Cottage Cheese Egg Muffins
SaveThese little muffins punch well above their size when it comes to protein. Made with eggs and cottage cheese as the base each muffin delivers a solid hit of protein in a form that is portable, meal-preppable and genuinely satisfying. You can customize the mix-ins with spinach, diced peppers, turkey or herbs without changing the core nutrition profile. Bake a tray on Sunday and you have easy high-protein lunches ready for the first half of the week. They reheat well and hold their texture making them one of the most practical lunch ideas for weight loss on this entire list.
Key Ingredients
Eggs, cottage cheese, spinach, bell pepper
Tip
Do not overbake. Pull them when the centers are just set for the best texture.
Who It Is For
Meal preppers, high-protein dieters and anyone avoiding bread.
2. Zesty Lime Shrimp and Avocado Salad
SaveShrimp is one of the leanest proteins available, high in protein and very low in calories and fast to cook. Paired with creamy avocado, fresh lime juice and crisp vegetables this salad manages to feel indulgent without being calorie-heavy. The lime and cilantro give it a brightness that makes it feel like something you would order at a restaurant rather than a diet meal. Avocado adds healthy fats that keep you full and help your body absorb fat-soluble vitamins from the vegetables alongside it. This comes together in about fifteen minutes and needs no cooking if you use pre-cooked shrimp.
Key Ingredients
Shrimp, avocado, lime, cucumber, red onion, cilantro
Tip
Add a pinch of chili flakes for extra heat and a slight metabolism boost.
Who It Is For
Anyone looking for a quick no-cook lunch with serious flavor.
3. Low Carb Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Bake
SaveIf you are the kind of person who needs a warm substantial lunch to feel satisfied this bake is built for you. It delivers the comfort of a creamy alfredo dish with a fraction of the carbohydrates by replacing pasta with broccoli florets that soak up the sauce beautifully. Chicken provides a strong protein base and the bake format means you can make a full dish and portion it out over several days. It reheats well in the microwave without losing its creamy texture making it one of the better meal prep options for cold-weather weeks when salads feel uninspiring.
Key Ingredients
Chicken breast, broccoli, parmesan, cream cheese, garlic
Tip
Use rotisserie chicken to cut prep time to under ten minutes.
Who It Is For
Low-carb dieters, meal preppers and comfort food lovers.
4. Chicken Mushroom Spinach
SaveThis is a clean whole-food lunch that does not try to be anything it is not. Sauteed chicken with mushrooms and spinach in a light pan sauce is exactly the kind of meal that supports consistent weight loss because it is genuinely satisfying, easy to make repeatedly and flexible enough to serve over cauliflower rice, regular rice or on its own depending on your carbohydrate goals for the day. Mushrooms add a meaty umami depth that makes this feel far more substantial than the ingredient list suggests. Spinach wilts down quickly and adds iron, magnesium and additional fiber.
Key Ingredients
Chicken breast, cremini mushrooms, fresh spinach, garlic, olive oil
Tip
Let the mushrooms brown properly before adding liquid. This is where the flavor comes from.
Who It Is For
Clean eaters and anyone on a calorie deficit who still wants a real meal.
5. Air Fryer Fish Tacos
SaveFish tacos have a reputation as a treat meal but built the right way they are a genuinely smart lunch for weight loss. Air-frying the fish instead of deep-frying dramatically reduces the fat content while keeping the exterior crispy and satisfying. White fish is naturally lean and high in protein and when you load the tacos with shredded cabbage, fresh salsa and a squeeze of lime you get volume, crunch and flavor that make this feel like anything but diet food. Use small corn tortillas and keep the toppings fresh rather than creamy to keep calories in check.
Key Ingredients
White fish fillets, corn tortillas, cabbage, lime, salsa
Tip
Season the fish generously. This is where most of the flavor lives.
Who It Is For
Anyone who gets bored eating the same protein sources and weekend meal makers.
Low-Calorie Salad Lunches That Actually Fill You Up
Salads get a bad reputation because most people build them wrong. Too little protein, too much dressing and not enough substance. These four are built differently.
6. Apple Almond Shrimp Salad
SaveThe combination of sweet apple, crunchy almonds and lean shrimp makes this one of the more interesting salads in this collection. It hits multiple textures and flavor profiles at once, sweet, savory, crunchy and tender, which is exactly what keeps a salad from feeling like a punishment. Shrimp keeps the protein high without adding significant calories and the apple adds natural sweetness that reduces the need for a sugary dressing. Almonds contribute healthy fats and a satisfying crunch that rounds out the bowl. This is a salad you will look forward to rather than just tolerate.
Key Ingredients
Shrimp, apple, sliced almonds, mixed greens, light vinaigrette
Tip
Use a simple lemon and olive oil dressing to keep calories low and flavors clean.
Who It Is For
Anyone who finds plain salads boring and those looking for a protein-forward lunch.
7. Honey Mustard on Romaine Salad
SaveRomaine is one of the best greens for a filling salad. It has a satisfying crunch, holds up well under dressing and provides a good amount of fiber and water content for its calorie count. The honey mustard dressing here is made lighter than the standard version without losing its characteristic sweet-tangy balance. Add a grilled chicken breast or hard-boiled egg on top and this becomes a complete high-protein lunch. If you are building a salad habit and want something that does not feel like a compromise this is a strong starting point.
Key Ingredients
Romaine, honey mustard dressing, croutons (optional) and protein of choice
Tip
Make the dressing in a jar and keep it in the fridge for quick assembly throughout the week.
Who It Is For
Salad beginners and those transitioning from heavier lunches.
For a lower-calorie dressing option across multiple salads our Caesar Salad Dressing Low Calorie is worth bookmarking.
8. Broccoli Salad Recipe No Mayo
SaveTraditional broccoli salad is often loaded with mayonnaise, sugar and bacon to the point where it no longer qualifies as a weight-loss option. This version strips that back without losing what makes broccoli salad worth eating. The result is a crunchy, tangy and slightly sweet salad that works as a standalone lunch or a side alongside grilled protein. Broccoli is one of the most nutrient-dense vegetables available, high in fiber, vitamin C and sulforaphane, a compound linked to reduced inflammation. Without the heavy mayo base the natural flavor of the broccoli comes through more clearly.
Key Ingredients
Broccoli florets, red onion, sunflower seeds, light dressing, dried cranberries
Tip
Let it sit for at least 20 minutes after dressing. The broccoli softens slightly and absorbs the flavor.
Who It Is For
Those avoiding mayo and anyone looking for a make-ahead salad that improves over time.
9. Imitation Crab Salad
SaveImitation crab is often overlooked in healthy eating conversations but it is low in fat, relatively high in protein and extremely affordable which makes it one of the more practical ingredients for everyday lunch prep. This salad keeps it simple. The crab is mixed with crisp celery, light mayo or Greek yogurt, lemon and herbs then served over greens or in a lettuce wrap for a complete meal. It takes about ten minutes to make and costs a fraction of what a comparable seafood salad would at a restaurant or deli counter. A genuinely useful recipe for busy weeks.
Key Ingredients
Imitation crab, celery, light mayo or Greek yogurt, lemon, dill
Tip
Greek yogurt as a mayo substitute cuts calories while adding protein.
Who It Is For
Budget-conscious meal preppers, seafood lovers and quick-lunch seekers.
Warm Soups and Bowls for a Satisfying Midday Meal
Research consistently shows that starting a meal with soup reduces overall calorie intake at that meal. These recipes take that principle seriously.
10. White Chicken Chili
SaveWhite chicken chili is one of the most reliable weight-loss lunch recipes in this collection because it checks every box simultaneously. High protein from chicken, excellent fiber from white beans, warming spices that make it satisfying even in small portions and a broth base that adds volume without adding significant calories. It freezes well which means you can make a large batch and pull portions out throughout the month. The white beans deserve particular attention here. They are one of the most filling foods you can add to a weight-loss diet thanks to their combination of resistant starch, fiber and plant protein.
Key Ingredients
Chicken breast, white beans, green chiles, chicken broth, cumin, garlic
Tip
Shred the chicken directly in the pot using two forks for the best texture.
Who It Is For
Batch cookers, those who need a filling hot lunch and anyone who loves chili.
11. Cabbage Soup Diet Recipe
SaveThe cabbage soup diet has existed for decades and the core insight behind it holds up. Cabbage-based soup is extraordinarily low in calories, high in volume and filling enough to serve as a meal anchor. This version is built to be genuinely enjoyable rather than punishing. It uses a well-seasoned vegetable broth base with tomatoes, onion, celery and plenty of cabbage to create a soup that tastes good and keeps hunger at bay for hours. At well under 150 calories per generous serving it is one of the most calorie-efficient lunches on this list. Pair it with a protein source to make it a complete meal.
Key Ingredients
Cabbage, tomatoes, onion, celery, vegetable broth, garlic, herbs
Tip
Add a can of drained white beans for protein without changing the flavor significantly.
Who It Is For
Anyone in a more aggressive calorie deficit and those who like high-volume eating.
12. Curried Chicken Lentil and Rice Soup with Spinach
SaveThis is the kind of lunch that leaves you genuinely satisfied for four or five hours. Lentils are among the most filling foods in any diet and combined with chicken, brown rice and spinach in a warming curry broth the result is a bowl that covers protein, fiber and complex carbohydrates in one serving. The curry spices including turmeric, cumin and coriander also provide anti-inflammatory benefits that go beyond basic nutrition. This soup reheats beautifully and actually improves the next day as the flavors develop making it a top-tier meal prep option.
Key Ingredients
Chicken, red lentils, brown rice, spinach, curry powder, light coconut milk
Tip
Use light coconut milk rather than full-fat to keep the calorie count reasonable without losing creaminess.
Who It Is For
Meal preppers and those who need maximum satiety from a single bowl.
13. Egg Flower Soup
SaveEgg drop soup is one of the most underrated weight-loss lunches available. It takes under ten minutes to make, requires almost no ingredients and is naturally low in calories while still providing a meaningful amount of protein from the eggs. The broth base is warming and satisfying in a way that suppresses appetite reliably. This version keeps it clean and traditional without unnecessary additions. It works particularly well as a starter before a slightly larger lunch portion or on days when your calorie target is lower and you need something light but not hollow.
Key Ingredients
Eggs, chicken broth, sesame oil, green onion, cornstarch
Tip
Pour the eggs in a thin slow stream while stirring gently for the best silky texture.
Who It Is For
Anyone wanting a fast ultra-low-calorie warm lunch.
14. Creamy Cabbage White Bean Soup
SaveWhere the cabbage soup diet recipe is intentionally lean this version is built for those who need something more substantial. White beans blended partially into the broth create a creamy rich texture without any added dairy. Cabbage provides volume and fiber while the beans supply both plant protein and resistant starch, a type of carbohydrate that feeds beneficial gut bacteria and has been linked to improved insulin sensitivity. This is the soup to make when you want something that feels indulgent but is still firmly within a weight-loss eating pattern. A thick hearty bowl that takes about 30 minutes start to finish.
Key Ingredients
Cabbage, white beans, vegetable or chicken broth, garlic, onion
Tip
Blend one third of the soup and stir it back in for a naturally creamy consistency.
Who It Is For
Those who find broth-only soups unsatisfying and plant-based lunch seekers.
Quick and Easy Lunch Ideas for Weight Loss
Consistency matters more than perfection. These recipes are designed for busy days when you need something fast, filling and genuinely good for your goals.
15. Mushroom and Spinach Zucchini Lasagna Loaf
SaveUsing zucchini in place of pasta sheets dramatically reduces the carbohydrate and calorie content of a lasagna-style dish while adding water content that contributes to fullness. This loaf format makes portioning straightforward. Slice and serve and the remaining portions keep well in the refrigerator for two to three days. Mushrooms and spinach provide fiber, plant-based nutrients and a savory depth that makes this feel like a real meal rather than a substitution. This is the recipe to reach for when you want something that satisfies a pasta craving without derailing your progress.
Key Ingredients
Zucchini, mushrooms, spinach, ricotta or cottage cheese, marinara, mozzarella
Tip
Salt and lightly squeeze the zucchini before assembling to reduce excess moisture.
Who It Is For
Low-carb dieters, vegetarians and pasta lovers managing their intake.
16. Spicy Salmon Rice Muffins
SaveSalmon is among the best proteins for weight loss, rich in omega-3 fatty acids that reduce inflammation, support brain function and may help regulate the hormones that control hunger. These rice muffins combine salmon with cooked rice and spicy seasoning in a baked muffin format that makes portioning and packing effortless. Each muffin is dense and satisfying and a serving of three or four covers both your protein and carbohydrate needs in a single compact lunch. They are also a good way to use leftover rice making them an efficient option for anyone already batch-cooking grains.
Key Ingredients
Canned or fresh salmon, cooked rice, sriracha or chili sauce, soy sauce, egg
Tip
Canned salmon works just as well as fresh here and costs significantly less.
Who It Is For
Meal preppers, omega-3 seekers and anyone who loves bold flavors.
17. Lazy Spanakopita Muffins
SaveTraditional spanakopita involves layering delicate phyllo pastry which is time-consuming and adds significant calories. This lazy muffin version captures all the flavor with spinach, feta, egg and herbs in a baked muffin format that takes a fraction of the effort. Each muffin is protein-forward thanks to the eggs and feta and the spinach adds iron and fiber that make this genuinely nutritious rather than just convenient. The flavor profile with salty feta, earthy spinach and fragrant dill is distinctive enough that these never feel boring even eaten multiple days in a row. A strong meal prep option for anyone who wants variety in their lunch rotation.
Key Ingredients
Spinach, feta cheese, eggs, dill, onion, flour or almond flour
Tip
Use frozen spinach squeezed completely dry to save prep time without sacrificing flavor.
Who It Is For
Mediterranean diet followers, meal preppers and those avoiding processed lunch foods.
18. Chicken Bacon and Ranch
SaveThis is the recipe for people who are reluctant to eat healthy because they associate it with food they do not enjoy. Chicken, bacon and ranch are universally loved flavor combinations and this version brings them together in a way that keeps the protein high while managing the fat content through portion awareness. Made as a casserole it is easy to portion, reheats well and genuinely satisfies the kind of hunger that sends people to the drive-through. A lighter ranch dressing and modest bacon use keep this in reasonable territory without stripping out the flavors that make it worth eating.
Key Ingredients
Chicken breast, turkey bacon or regular bacon, light ranch, cheese
Tip
Use turkey bacon to reduce saturated fat without losing the smoky flavor.
Who It Is For
Picky eaters, those transitioning from fast food habits and families eating the same lunch.
19. Balsamic Skirt Steak with Red Pepper Relish and Zucchini Salad
SaveSkirt steak is a lean flavorful cut that cooks in under ten minutes and delivers a serious protein payoff. The balsamic marinade tenderizes the meat and adds a slight sweetness that pairs well with the bright acidity of the red pepper relish. The zucchini salad alongside adds volume and crunch without meaningful calories making the whole plate feel generous even at a moderate calorie count. This is the kind of lunch that does not feel like it belongs in a weight-loss plan and that is precisely what makes it sustainable. Eating food you genuinely enjoy is the most reliable long-term strategy.
Key Ingredients
Skirt steak, balsamic vinegar, red peppers, zucchini, olive oil, herbs
Tip
Slice the steak thin against the grain for maximum tenderness with minimal effort.
Who It Is For
Red meat lovers and those who need a high-protein lunch with real staying power.
Meal Prep Lunch Ideas for Weight Loss
Preparing lunches in advance removes the midday decision entirely. These five recipes are specifically suited to batch cooking and refrigerator storage.
20. Low Carb Kung Pao Chicken
SaveKung Pao chicken is a high-flavor dish that translates well to weight-loss meal prep when you reduce the sugar and serve it over cauliflower rice or a small portion of regular rice. The combination of chili heat, savory sauce and crunchy peanuts creates a satisfying complexity that makes this one of the more enjoyable options in any lunch rotation. The chicken is high in protein, the peanuts add healthy fats that extend satiety and the low-carb adaptation keeps blood sugar stable through the afternoon. Make a double batch and portion into containers for four days of lunches that actually taste better the second day.
Key Ingredients
Chicken breast, peanuts, dried chilies, soy sauce, rice vinegar, cauliflower rice
Tip
Toast the peanuts briefly before adding them. It significantly deepens their flavor.
Who It Is For
Low-carb dieters, takeout lovers reducing restaurant spending and meal preppers.
21. Slow Cooker Creamy Lemon Herb Chicken
SaveThe slow cooker is one of the most underused tools in weight-loss cooking. You assemble the ingredients in the morning and by lunchtime or evening the work is done with tender flavorful chicken in a light creamy lemon herb sauce that pairs with almost anything. This recipe is intentionally versatile. Serve it over greens, with roasted vegetables, over a small portion of rice or with zucchini noodles depending on your carbohydrate goals. The lemon keeps the flavor profile bright and clean preventing the richness of the sauce from feeling heavy. An excellent anchor recipe for a weekly meal prep routine.
Key Ingredients
Chicken breast, lemon, garlic, fresh herbs, light cream or Greek yogurt, chicken broth
Tip
Stir in the cream or yogurt at the very end to prevent curdling.
Who It Is For
Busy people, those who want hands-off cooking and anyone building a weekly lunch prep habit.
22. Cransational Chicken Salad
SaveA well-made chicken salad is one of the most practical weight-loss lunch staples because it requires minimal cooking, stores well for four to five days and is endlessly adaptable. This version adds dried cranberries and a touch of sweetness that balances the savory chicken base creating something that stands on its own rather than needing to be hidden in a sandwich. Use Greek yogurt in place of some of the mayo to push the protein content higher while reducing the calorie density. Serve on lettuce cups, with cucumber slices or in a small whole-grain wrap depending on your preferences.
Key Ingredients
Cooked chicken, dried cranberries, celery, Greek yogurt, light mayo, herbs
Tip
Rotisserie chicken shredded by hand gives the best texture for chicken salad.
Who It Is For
Lunch preppers, those avoiding hot food and anyone who needs a grab-and-go option.
23. Beef and Pepper Rice Bowl
SaveRice bowls are among the most meal-prep-friendly formats available and this beef and pepper version hits a strong balance of protein, carbohydrate and vegetables in a single container. The beef provides iron and protein, the peppers add vitamin C and fiber and the rice base can be adjusted with brown rice for more fiber, cauliflower rice for fewer carbs or a mix of both. The seasoning is savory and slightly spicy which makes this one of the more craveable options in a meal prep rotation. It holds well in the refrigerator for three to four days and reheats in under two minutes.
Key Ingredients
Ground beef or sliced beef, bell peppers, onion, soy sauce, garlic, rice
Tip
Use 90% lean ground beef to keep the fat content reasonable without sacrificing flavor.
Who It Is For
Meal preppers, those who need a hearty lunch and anyone building balanced bowls.
24. Teriyaki Pineapple Chicken and Rice Stuffed Peppers
SaveStuffed peppers are a natural portion-control vehicle. The pepper itself defines the serving size which removes the need to measure or weigh your food. This teriyaki and pineapple version is sweet, savory and satisfying in a way that feels entirely unlike diet food. The pineapple adds natural sweetness and a mild acidity that brightens the teriyaki sauce and the combination with lean chicken and rice delivers a complete balanced meal in a visually appealing format. Make four to six at once and store them in the refrigerator for a week of lunches that require nothing more than reheating.
Key Ingredients
Bell peppers, chicken breast, rice, teriyaki sauce, pineapple chunks
Tip
Use brown rice for extra fiber or cauliflower rice if you are keeping carbs lower.
Who It Is For
Meal preppers, those who benefit from built-in portion control and families.
25. Chicken Burrito Casserole
SaveA burrito casserole takes all the flavor of a burrito bowl without the need to assemble individual portions and it scales easily for meal prep. This version is built with chicken, black beans, salsa and a moderate amount of cheese baked together into a dish that is rich in protein and fiber. Black beans are one of the most effective hunger-suppressing foods available and the combination of beans and chicken means this casserole holds you genuinely satisfied through the afternoon. Cut into portions, refrigerate and reheat throughout the week. Add a simple green salad alongside and you have a complete well-balanced lunch.
Key Ingredients
Chicken breast, black beans, salsa, brown rice, cheese, cumin
Tip
Layer salsa generously. It keeps the casserole moist during reheating.
Who It Is For
Families, meal preppers and those who want burrito flavors without the extra calories.
FAQ
If you love simple wellness recipes, do not miss this blue salt weight loss recipe.
If you love light snacks, do not miss this pink gelatin weight loss recipe.
If you love easy recipes, do not miss this oat weight loss drink.
If you love filling meals, do not miss these ground beef weight loss dinners.
If you love wellness guides, check out this what to eat with weight-loss peptides.
What should I eat for lunch to lose weight?
How many calories should a weight-loss lunch have?
Are salads really good for weight loss?
What is the best high-protein lunch for weight loss?
Can I meal prep lunches for the whole week?
What foods should I avoid at lunch for weight loss?
Is soup a good lunch for weight loss?
Final Thoughts
Finding lunch ideas for weight loss that you genuinely want to eat is the single most underrated part of any successful eating plan. The recipes in this guide are not about restriction. They are about building a midday meal that is satisfying, nutritious and sustainable enough to eat repeatedly without feeling like a compromise.
Start with two or three recipes from this list, add them to a simple weekly meal prep routine and pay attention to how different lunches affect your afternoon hunger. The data you collect from your own body is more useful than any general advice.
For a broader look at meals that support weight loss across every part of your day visit our full collection of 22 Best Homemade Weight Loss Recipes That Actually Work and our guide to 11 Best Homemade Weight Loss Drinks.
If you make any of these recipes share them with us on social media. We would love to see what you create.

Comments
Leave a comment
Your email will not be published. New comments are reviewed before appearing.